I've maintained a profile on a popular dating site for some time. It doesn't lead to much but interesting conversations which is fine. However, I'm completely up front about who (and "what") I am on that site, because I don't want to talk to 100 people only to have 97 or 98 of them turn away in shock when they do find out. I'd rather talk to 2 or 3 who might actually want to talk to me. If we did wind up meeting in person and going out on a date, I don't want a difficult, dangerous situation to arise. Yes, I've allowed myself to go there before, but it was not something I set out to do nor something I care to repeat. It's too dangerous. Even though I'm very explicit about my past in my profile, a lot of people don't read it or don't understand, and run the other way once they realize, but most people are actually very nice about it. In fact, I've had the distinct pleasure of interacting with several people online who were truly wonderful, thoughtful, and even encouraging to me. The word "courageous" comes up often. I don't think I'm courageous, but it's humbling to know that so many people think that. Unfortunately, every once in a while someone comes along with so much unprovoked, vile hatred toward me that it reminds me how far we trans people have yet to go - and then I feel like throwing up. Then I feel unsafe, vulnerable.
Today, I encountered one such hate-filled individual. He apparently had wandered across my pictures on the aforementioned site, and clearly read my entire profile before sending me this vicious message:
I thought about Mr. Notadouche over dinner. Isn't it funny how we can get maybe ten positive, praising comments and almost dismiss them, but when a single, solitary negative one comes along it is so hard to just let it go? I've heard it said that's the case because the good stuff is harder for most of us to believe about ourselves than the bad. But I wasn't thinking about this person because I believe anything he said. I thought long and hard about those sorts of questions for many years. I would not have transitioned if I thought there was any possibility of truth in such beliefs. Still, I did think about him. He reminded me of something.
Mr. Notadouche reminded me of a situation that my therapist, Erin Swenson, shared with our support group one time several months back. Erin talked about a time when she was at some venue giving a seminar about transsexualism to a large group of people. She told them that sometimes they may encounter someone after the talk who will come up to them and express very angry, bitter feelings about Erin having been there and about her discussions on transsexualism and people who transition genders. Erin asked them to be especially kind to the people who do exactly that, because, as Erin pointed out, those are likely to be the very people who are struggling themselves with their own gender issues, and not able to come to terms with them. This is likely quite true, but even if it were not true, it's quite a powerful psychological tool with which to arm one's self in such a situation.
I'm not as eloquent and even tempered as my therapist - not even close. I'm not a trained, professional orator as she is, but I do tend to be pretty crafty with the words. Oh yeah! More importantly, I feel a sense of duty and obligation to help out my fellow trans people - even the ones in deep denial such as Mr. Notadouche. So, after dinner I decided to share some wisdom with him. I couldn't be quite as Gandhi-like as my therapist, but I gave it my best shot. This is what I wrote:
Dear Mr. Notadouche,
You know, I was thinking about it, and I realize that the only reason you'd have such a violently negative reaction to my very existence is that you yourself must be suffering from seriously conflicted feelings about your own gender - and seeing me stirs up those feelings, making it harder for you to hide them, and not think about them, not admit to yourself what you really are. A lot of my friends have transitioned quite successfully and now live full-time as women and are accepted completely as such just like myself. Some of them, like you, started off as very hateful, bitter, homophobic, transphobic guys. Others, also like you, gravitated toward high risk, hyper-masculine professions (police officers, Special Forces and other military, and fire fighters - just like you). Over time, they came to realize that all that excessive proving themselves as "men" was their way to cope with this deep, dark, shameful secret that they harbored. I bet it must be very hard for you to live that way. I remember that feeling - like life was not worth living because it was a complete facade. It wasn't me.
My daughter is great, because she has two parents who love her, instead of one living and one dead or emotionally unstable parent. Don't worry about my family. Worry about your own - if you have anyone who loves you. Do they know the real you? I'm in and out of women's locker rooms and restrooms every day, because I live this way - 24/7. Never a strange look. Not one. Why? Because I don't look like a man in lipstick, silly. I imagine you probably cross dress sometimes, and then feel so ashamed afterward, repulsed at your own image in the mirror, because you haven't undergone female puberty as I have. You haven't had your facial hair removed yet as I have. So, you surely look like a man in make-up and a dress when you dress up, and when you fantasize about it. And I know you do. I want you to know it's okay. You don't have to be ashamed. There are support groups you can go to. There are therapists who will guide you.
I know a woman who transitioned a while back who is a firefighter like you in another city, and her squad is totally behind her. They respect her courage for dealing with this thing people like she and I are forced to deal with. Did you know that the American Medical Association's latest stance on transsexualism is that it is, in fact, a serious medical condition? It's true. They once thought of it as purely psychological, but they have reversed themselves after years of evidence to the contrary have piled up. They've learned from the facts. Educate yourself, and do the same.
I hope you find some peace in your life that you are obviously sorely lacking. Until then, maybe you should stop seeking out people you think look like guys in lipstick - unless you're attracted to guys in lipstick. Is that it? Are you struggling to suppress your homosexual urges? I mean, if you ARE a homosexual - just admit it and you will feel better. Life is so much better when you don't have to live a lie anymore. You can do it. You can. In the meantime, when you come across other people who are honest with themselves and who choose to be healthy and happy and find what is normal and right for them, when you come across those people, people like me, who are not bothering you, who should not threaten you in any way unless you are afraid that you are really one of them, you should just keep your ignorant mouth shut, and go about your life and let others do the same. Doing otherwise just calls you out as being ashamed and hiding something of your own.
By the way, when you choose a username like "NotADouche34", you clue people into the fact that you must be a douche instantly. Why else would you feel so compelled to defend yourself before the accusation has even been made? Stop hiding and living a lie, and I promise you won't feel like a douche anymore. It's hard, because occasionally you will come across people who treat you the way you've treated me. But it's worth it, because living an authentic, true life is worth any price. You can do it. Good luck.
If any of you who is reading this can guess what dating site this might be, feel free to drop by and visit Mr. Notadouche's profile often. Add him to your favorites list. Even send him a sweet, encouraging message if you feel so compelled. I have a feeling he genuinely needs the support of the trans community, and we are nothing if not supportive of our own. Well, that's been my experience so far, and one that touches me deeply. Thank you.







